Monday, April 23, 2012

Slow Down, Refresh Your Memory: how far the Royals have come

I, like every other Royals fan, am absolutely depressed.  The Royals still are not good.  They are so not good they might go 0-10 on their first home stand of 2012.  A number of factors have contributed to this current debacle, but now is not the time to talk about that.  Now is also not the time to talk about firing anyone, especially the General Manager. 

Dayton Moore became the Royals GM in June of 2006, and has proceeded to completely overhaul the entire Royals organization.  To illustrate the progress of this Royals organization I want to take a look at the 2005 Royals roster and compare it to the current roster to show just how far the team has come over the past 6 seasons.  Not surprisingly, not a single player appears on both lists.  I honestly have no memory of the 2005 Royals (I count myself among the lucky ones) because I did not live in the United States at the time and I did not even remember a number of these guys ever being Royals.  I hope your stomach is ready, because this roster is going to make you feel sick.

Pos Player
C John Buck
1B Matt Stairs
2B Ruben Gotay
SS Angel Berroa
3B Mark Teahen
LF Terrence Long
CF David DeJesus
RF Emil Brown
DH Mike Sweeney
Bench Tony Graffanino
JoeMcEwing
Chip Ambres
Aaron Guiel
Alberto Castillo
Eli Marrero
Ken Harvey
1 Zack Greinke
2 Jose Lima
3 Runelvys Hernandez
4 DJ Carrasco
5 JP Howell
Pen Mike MacDougal
Mike Wood
Andy Sisco
Ambiorix Burgos
Jeremy Affeldt

Wow, by my count, I only see 6 legitimate Major League ballplayers out of 26 total.  Since 2005 only Buck, DeJesus, Sweeney, Greinke, Howell, and Affeldt have had any significant success in the big leagues, and only Greinke would be considered an above average player.  Mike Sweeney was great at one time, but he would never again play enough games to be of any value to his team.  Not exactly a murderers row, but the Royals did have one murderer on their team.  Ambiorix Burgos would go on to kill a woman in a hit and run accident and then was charged with the attempted murder of his wife.

If you think the Major League roster from 2005 looks bad, the minor league prospects are going to make you lose your mind.  Billy Butler was the top prospect (turned out alright), along with Denny Bautista, Shane Costa, Mark Teahen, Mitch Maier, and Chris Lubanski.  YUCK!

Now, let us look at the makeup of the current roster; I have inserted injured players (highlighted in yellow) in the positions they will fill when healthy:

Pos Player
C  Salvador Perez
1B Eric Hosmer
2B Yuni Betancourt
SS Alcides Escobar
3B Mike Moustakas
LF Alex Gordon
CF Lorenzo Cain
RF Jeff Francoeur
DH Billy Butler
Bench Brayan Pena
Mitch Maier
Chris Getz
Jason Bourgeois
Johnny Giavotella
1 Bruce Chen
2 Luke Hochevar
3 Jonathan Sanchez
4 Felipe Paulino
5 Danny Duffy
Pen Jonathan Broxton
Aaron Crow
Greg Holland
Tim Collins
Everett Teaford
Louis Coleman
Kelvin Herrera
Joakim Soria

If we had a time machine that would make all the players from 2005 the same age as their counterparts in 2012 there would not be a single player that would start for Royals, with the exception of  Zack Greinke and maybe David DeJesus.  The Royals really were that bad.  In 2005 they lost 106 games and nobody really knows how they managed to win 56.  If we as fans want to root for teams that take on enormous challenges we have to be patient and remember how far we have come.  I don't know if the this current group of players will ever become a consistent winner, but the future sure looks a lot brighter than it did 7 years ago.

No comments:

Post a Comment